The Ugly Betty actress seems so fresh-faced and natural here, it’s almost like she’s makeup free! But look a little closer, and you’ll detect a hint of bronze in an updated smoky eye that’s just too chic. To get her subtle-yet-sexy makeup look, try a gold and bronze eyeshadow palette that gives you the freedom to mix the perfect shade for your skin, and don’t forget to line your eyes—top and bottom—with a little bit of color. Finish things off with a sheer and natural balm, and you’ll look fresh and fab, too!

1. LORAC Starry-Eyed Baked Eyeshadow Trio in Superstar, $24 at Sephora.com.

2. Soft Touch Shadow Pencil in Skorpios, $24 at NARSCosmetics.com.

3. 24/7 Natural Lip Sheer with SPF 15 in Tea Time, $14 at TarteCosmetics.com.