For one night only, pink pillows, diamond encrusted baseball bats, pink koozies, and a Victoria’s Secret Pink branded photobooth dominated the otherwise very manly MLB Fan Cave. No, this wasn’t a bet gone awry, but rather a celebration of all things Pink and MLB!

To toast to the expansion of the lingerie brand’s baseball themed collection, Victoria’s Secret Pink brought together one of their go-to Pink gals, Elsa Hosk, Glee hearthrob Chord Overstreet, and a whole selection of ball players from New York Yankees pitcher CC Sabathia to third baseman Eric Chavez to left fielder Brett Gardner. Over cake pops and strawberry lemonade, the girls partied until late in the evening, dancing to everyone’s favorite song – Call Me Maybe – and snapping pics while the boys took up residence on couches upstairs, getting in their sports fix, while lounging on Pink pillows, of course.

Now the question is, who’s placing bets on how long it will take before those Pink koozies become a favorite for baseball games and tailgates!